"The cottage which had a sea view, was beautifully maintained and very comfortable. Housekeeping was outstanding throughout our stay."

October 19, 2014

"Beautiful view from ocean view room, good bed, balcony, quiet, decent breakfast..."

September 8, 2014

"The accommodations were very clean. The housekeeping and management were great!"

August 27, 2014

"Enjoyed a girlfriends getaway and enjoyed 2 nights with 2 rooms in the main lodge. A great visit on Martha's Vineyard!!"

May 14, 2014

"...couldn't have been better for a quick fall getaway...The rustic charm is exactly the kind of thing we like and just what were looking for."

November 1, 2013

"This is probably my favorite place to visit anywhere in the U.S."

October 6, 2013

"I would not go to one of the more popular hotels because I enjoyed the sense of uniqueness this inn offers. LOVED IT..."

September 10, 2013

"The Inn has beautiful grounds and lots of charm and great views."

September 3, 2013

"Breakfast was great every morning...staff to management is so relaxed and happy to help with any issues."

September 3, 2013

Captain's House

Located in the Marsh Hill Compound, which includes three vacation homes with spectacular views over Menemsha Harbor, Captain's House is part of a classic antique vineyard "camp" that sits below the Beach Plum Inn on the Hill overlooking the ocean.

This rustic house is a throwback to a bygone era. Built in the early 1900's, it offers comfortable 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom character lodging perfect for those seeking a more authentic beach house experience in Martha's Vineyard.

With easy beach access and steps away from the pool, Captain's House is a perennial favorite for beachcombers, swimmers and daydreamers looking for a laid back holiday on the shores of Menemsha.

Captain's House accommodates up to 6 guests and features:

  • three bedrooms
  • three bathrooms
  • screen deck
  • full kitchen
  • cable television
  • VCR/DVD player
  • outside shower
  • BBQ grill
  • daily housekeeping
  • use of all the Inns facilities
  • parking pass for Lucy Vincent beach
  • complimentary firewood

Check Availability